Mike Commenting on Safety
Recently I wrote a post about safety while tramping and just now this post received a comment from Mike McGavin. Mike’s comment makes a good point, and I would like to post it as a separate post, so it would get more attention. So here is Mike’s comment:
” Hi Greg. I stumbled on your blog this evening and it looks really impressive. Thanks for putting it together, and I’ve subscribed to the rss.
I just thought I’d comment that I think around the Tongariro area (especially the crossing) must be one of the most frequent places all over New Zealand for people to go unprepared. That particular daywalk (the Tongariro Crossing) is the most popular daywalk in New Zealand, and I’m not an expert but I suspect the whole thing is at least partly because people factor a single day to walk the Crossing, but don’t take into account that their preferred day might simply have bad weather.
When we walked it, there was a lot of clag around, and strong icy-cold winds in several exposed places. We were completely covered up, visibility was about 10 metres, and were near having out maps and compasses (possibly a GPS) just in case. Still, we were surrounded by hundreds of people throughout the day who looked to be completely and absolutely unprepared. Most probably would have started because they really wanted to do it, but hadn’t planned for not being able to, and there were definitely people who should have been turning around near the start (but often didn’t) because they weren’t coping well with fitness and could have gotten themselves into terrible problems given the conditions. I honestly came away with the impression that some day in the future a bad storm’s going to come through without much warning and wipe 50 people off the mountain.
I’ve heard some really absurd stories about that area too from other people I’ve met, ranging from people trying to cross the mountain wearing high heels (without realising it’s not actually that kind of footpath) through to certain people who’d just finished military training and ditched one of their friends who they lost without bothering to report it. (With all that military training he could probably look after himself and get back on his own, after all.) That last one was a story from a Department of Conservation ranger who’d been stationed at a hut at the time, and came across the chap in jeans and a t-shirt unable to find his mates.
They’re sort of funny stories in some respects, but the disturbing part is that I still think it’s a matter of time before something really seriously bad happens. It really says something for making sure you’re properly prepared, and also be mentally prepared to not go at all if that’s what it takes on the day. ”
Mike McGavin has his own site named Windy Hilltops, where he talks a lot about his tramping experiences.
No related posts.




December 19th, 2008 at 3:16 pm
Kia ora Greg,
I have to agree with Mike. Having done the Tongariro walk numerous times I have always thought it is a disaster waiting to happen. The level of overall unpreparedness for not only a high alpine walk with no shelter should things go bad, but also simply the duration of the walk – at least 6 plus hours for a fit tramper, is shocking. I am told the tour operators, or those who organize the bus pick ups and drop offs, are getting more diligent about checking what people are wearing and taking, but I suspect a little of the Kiwi “she’ll be right” attitude is still at work. My advice is to take responsibility for your self, and on a walk like Tongariro I would never be without hat gloves, extra warm garment, rain jacket, thermals, water, food, and possibly even a bivvy bag, just in case. People tend to forget how fast conditions can change up there.
I just returned from the South Island, and got in a few walks. One in particular I climbed up into the mist in the Korowai/Torlesse Tussocklands where it started to sleet and get windy. As much as I wanted to carry my lack of gear and familiarity with the terrain turned me around. It is really about making the right decisions. Good topic. Have a great Christmas Greg!
Rangimarie,
Robb
December 20th, 2008 at 4:21 am
Hi Robb!
!
Have a great Christmas yourself
Great to hear that you had a good time on the South Island. I red all about it on your blog.